Rigel wrote: |
Hello,
Does islam disallow woman to marry non muslims? people of the books, or the others ? Thank you |
AhmedBahgat wrote: | ||
Salam mate Islam forbids that Muslims being male or female to marry from Al Mushrikoon, and I believe that Ahl Al Kitab should be classified as Mushrikoon Take care |
Windsor wrote: |
Dr. Ahmed Sobhy Mansour disagrees with you brother. |
Windsor wrote: |
He says Muslims can marry non-Muslims, except those who wage war/hate Islam and Muslims. |
Rigel wrote: |
Meantime I request AB to please tell in detail.
Salam |
Rigel wrote: |
Thank you Windsor, I know there are 2 groups of people some agree and some disagree on this. I have not read Dr. Ahmed Sobhy Mansour but I certainly stand with brother AB for uptil now there is no argument by him which I disagree with, except one thats shahada but thats also on technical terms.
Windsor can you please post Dr.Sobhy view on the subject. Meantime I request AB to please tell in detail. Salam |
AhmedBahgat wrote: | ||
Salam brother I actually like and respect Dr Mansour, I have read and continue to read many of his writings in Arabic on his Ahl Al Quran web site, however there are many things that I can't acceot it from him, the only reason for that is simply, the Quran message where is is clear to understand tey he comees with differnt opinion that mostely based on the Feel Good Religion Attitude |
Windsor wrote: |
I agree with your first statement. In my opinion he is the most knowledgeable Muslim scholar today, and he is the reason why I accepted the Quran alone message. I however tend to disagree with your second statement. He is a very experienced and honest scholar and genuinely believes in his opinions, and usually backs them up with Quranic evidences.
Peace. |
Rigel wrote: |
Jew/Christian are people of book and in my opinion believers too but their domain is different, now when POB meet muslim they discuss faith, now if POB reject quran, then POB becomes unbeliever. Shall I conclude that POB are believers BUT if they come across Quran they have 2 options to accept or reject. Once they reject they become unbelievers ? |
Rigel wrote: |
SITUATION CRITICAL!
Hello all, Sometime before hajj this year I was chatting with muslim fellow member of fi, who happens to be in love with a christan girl and he told me that he intends to marry her soon. My friend went to hajj happy happy and just returned to read FI. lol!!! Very sorry but I think you should explain once more this issue of marrying people of the book. Becasue my friend is still confused and speechless now. Due to privacy I cant name the member. salam |
Rigel wrote: |
Thankyou again brother AB, I hope our fi member is content by now. |
Rigel wrote: |
Anyway this is for my own info, we can marry pob once they accept quran and reject their false belief. So far so good, but about others? |
Rigel wrote: |
Muslim, can marry pob provided pob accepts islam.
POB, can marry muslim if accepts islam. Others ????? |
Rigel wrote: |
My common sense tells me, being muslim we shld marry muslim, anyother must 1st become muslim else bye bye!
salam |